Slip Lead vs Regular Dog Collar: Which is Better?

The gear you use when walking your dog can affect their safety, comfort, and behaviour. While a traditional collar and leash can work well for some dogs, certain canines need specific training tools for walks, such as slip leads.

While collars rest on your dog’s neck and can attach to a leash, slip leads are a leash and collar in one. Collars are great for everyday wear while slip leads can be used to contain escape artists and help with leash training. Both options are beneficial for different scenarios, so it’s a good idea to know the correct way to use each one.

Understanding Each Option

Most dogs wear a standard flat collar, which is the most common collar type. These collars can hold your dog’s ID tags on a daily basis, and they can connect to a clip-on leash during walks. They’re simple, practical, and versatile. 

A slip lead differs because you don’t need to connect it to a collar. This lead has a loop at the end that slides over your dog’s head and tightens. When your dog pulls, it tightens further, and when they relax, it loosens slightly. It’s commonly used at shelters to prevent dogs from escaping, but it can also be used as a training tool when paired with positive reinforcement.

The key difference is that slip leads apply pressure to a dog’s neck for security and correction while regular collars are for everyday wear and identification. Most dogs benefit from having a collar, but you might need a slip lead too if your dog is a flight risk or needs to work on leash manners.

Pros and Cons

There’s no right or wrong answer to what walking gear your dog needs. You know your dog best, so consider the benefits of each product to decide if it’s right for your pup.

Slip Lead

Pros:

• Quick and easy to put on

• Offers control for short training sessions

• Prevents dogs from escaping

• Can help correct pulling when paired with positive reinforcement

Cons:

• Not safe for constant wear

• Can cause neck injuries if used incorrectly

• Must be paired with training for best results

Regular Collar

Pros:

• Variety of colours and styles available

• Holds ID tags

• Comfortable for daily wear

• Great for walking dogs with good leash manners

Cons:

• Doesn’t offer much control when training

• Might encourage pulling

• Can slip off narrow-headed dogs

Training and Safety Considerations

Regular dog collars don’t add much to training sessions, but slip leads can make a huge impact when used correctly. Do not use slip leads for daily walks, especially if your dog has never worn one before. Instead, use them during closely supervised training sessions to ensure the loop doesn’t tighten too much and hurt your dog’s neck.

When training your dog with a slip lead, the goal is to teach them that when the leash tightens, they should stop instead of pulling. When your dog pauses and checks in with you when their slip lead tightens, reward them with a training treat. By focusing on positive reinforcement, you’re helping them associate proper leash manners with something good.

Since slip leads adjust in size, they can fit any dog. Yet, it’s still important to ensure proper fitting when putting a slip lead on. First, create a loop that’s bigger than your dog’s head and gently slide it on them. Tighten the leash around their neck with the leash resting on the back of their neck. The lead’s resting position should be snug with enough room for you to slide two fingers between your dog’s neck and the leash. Never leave your dog unattended while wearing a slip lead.

Ideally, you should switch between slip leads and collars depending on the context. Keep a collar on for casual walks but bring out a slip lead when it’s time to work on training.

Product Recommendations

Dog parents use collars and leads when they’re active with their pups, such as walking, hiking, and training. So, these items must withstand the wear and tear of frequent movements. True Charlie Co. offers walking gear, including collars and slip leads, that are the perfect balance between durable and comfortable for long-term use.

Other trusted brands include Rogz, which offers leads and collars for every lifestyle, and Mendota Pet, which offers durable gear for intense outdoor adventures. No matter what brand you choose, make sure the walking gear is the ideal fit for your dog. If you’re buying in-person, try it on your dog, but if you’re shopping online, get your dog’s neck measurements.

Slip Leads and Regular Collars Work for Different Occasions

Both slip leads and flat collars are great tools to have, but they’re meant for different situations. Slip leads help with training and short-term control, but regular collars are for daily wear and holding identification tags.

With any dog walking gear, you should focus on creating safe, positive training sessions. Doing so can make training fun while setting your dog up for success. If you’re ever unsure what training tools are right for your dog, consider their temperament, training stage, and comfort when making your decision. For personalised advice, consult a professional trainer.

If you’re ready to get new walking gear for your furry friend that’s durable and comfortable, explore True Charlie Co.’s wide selection of slip leads and collars. Find one that perfectly fits your dog’s size and lifestyle.